Email list hosting service & mailing list manager

floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (18 Dec 2003 02:58 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Ken Dickey (18 Dec 2003 16:17 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (19 Dec 2003 01:55 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Ken Dickey (20 Dec 2003 02:34 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (20 Dec 2003 08:56 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments bear (20 Dec 2003 19:00 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (22 Dec 2003 02:16 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments bear (23 Dec 2003 02:01 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (23 Dec 2003 04:38 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Ken Dickey (22 Dec 2003 02:56 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Per Bothner (20 Dec 2003 18:05 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Ken Dickey (22 Dec 2003 00:41 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (22 Dec 2003 03:50 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Ken Dickey (22 Dec 2003 17:05 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (23 Dec 2003 05:23 UTC)
Re: floating point and other comments Alex Shinn (23 Dec 2003 05:26 UTC)

Re: floating point and other comments Per Bothner 20 Dec 2003 18:05 UTC

Ken Dickey wrote:

>>>On Thursday 18 December 2003 03:55 am, Alex Shinn wrote:
>>>
>>>>... I think that an intermediate format should at least ... include
>>>>support for floating point formatting with ~F (I think ~E and ~G would
>>>>be advanced).
>
> I agree with your motives, but as a scheme implementation is not required to
> support floating point, I can't see adding such support here.

So what?  A Scheme implementation isn't required to support format.
Besides, ~F isn't restricted to "floating point".  It's obviously
useful for "fixed point" as well ... or generally any Scheme
implementation that supports non-integer reals, exact or in-exact.

I think an "intermediate format" that doesn't support "~8,2F" is
missing the boat.
--
	--Per Bothner
xxxxxx@bothner.com   http://per.bothner.com/