NaN's Paul Schlie (29 Oct 2005 15:50 UTC)
Re: NaN's Marcin 'Qrczak' Kowalczyk (29 Oct 2005 16:39 UTC)
Re: NaN's Paul Schlie (29 Oct 2005 18:22 UTC)
Re: NaN's Marcin 'Qrczak' Kowalczyk (29 Oct 2005 19:14 UTC)
Re: NaN's Paul Schlie (29 Oct 2005 22:49 UTC)
Error objects in general bear (29 Oct 2005 19:46 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Marcin 'Qrczak' Kowalczyk (29 Oct 2005 20:22 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general bear (30 Oct 2005 05:57 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Marcin 'Qrczak' Kowalczyk (30 Oct 2005 14:17 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Alan Watson (29 Oct 2005 21:26 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general bear (30 Oct 2005 05:40 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Taylor Campbell (30 Oct 2005 05:45 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general bear (30 Oct 2005 06:08 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Taylor Campbell (30 Oct 2005 16:49 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Alan Watson (30 Oct 2005 05:54 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general bear (30 Oct 2005 06:07 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Alan Watson (30 Oct 2005 06:46 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Paul Schlie (30 Oct 2005 12:39 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Paul Schlie (30 Oct 2005 13:04 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general John.Cowan (30 Oct 2005 16:30 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Alan Watson (30 Oct 2005 20:29 UTC)
Re: Error objects in general Alan Watson (30 Oct 2005 13:17 UTC)

Re: Error objects in general Alan Watson 30 Oct 2005 20:29 UTC

Paul Schlie wrote:
> Overall the question is: if NaN's (aka <indeterminate>/<void> values) are
> to be embraced, should their observable effect be more generally defined
> throughout the entire language specification? (As otherwise the ambiguities
> they represent may either be obscured by subsequent evaluations, or result
> in potentially undesirable non-easily foreseen halting errors?)

It seems reasonable to specify:

(a) The rules for arithmetic on NaNs.

(b) The behaviour of eqv? on NaNs.

(c) The read and write syntax of NaNs, if these exist.

(d) That calling inexact->exact on a NaN signals an error.

Provided one maintains (d), the effects of NaNs are limited.

Regards,

Alan
--
Dr Alan Watson
Centro de Radioastronomía y Astrofísica
Universidad Astronómico Nacional de México