Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly) John Cowan (28 Sep 2012 00:25 UTC)
|
Re: Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly)
David A. Wheeler
(29 Sep 2012 18:46 UTC)
|
Re: Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly)
David A. Wheeler
(29 Sep 2012 18:58 UTC)
|
Re: Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly)
John Cowan
(29 Sep 2012 19:27 UTC)
|
Re: Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly)
David A. Wheeler
(29 Sep 2012 20:42 UTC)
|
Re: Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly)
Per Bothner
(29 Sep 2012 21:00 UTC)
|
Re: Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly)
David A. Wheeler
(30 Sep 2012 00:26 UTC)
|
Re: Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly)
David A. Wheeler
(30 Sep 2012 00:31 UTC)
|
Cleaning up SRFI 105 MUSTard (mostly) John Cowan 28 Sep 2012 00:25 UTC
The spec fails to say that s-expressions are n-expressions. For "We encourage implementations to *always* implement curly-infix expressions" read "Implementations SHOULD implement c-expressions". For "Applications should" read "Applications SHOULD". For "We recommend that portable applications do *not*" read "Applications SHOULD NOT". For "We encourage implementations' *default* invocation" read "An implementation's default implementation SHOULD", and remove ", but this is not required". As mentioned earlier, remove the sentence about "curly-foo" What is said about defining "nfx" should also be said about "$bracket-access$". For "(curly-infix-read . port)" read something like "curly-infix-read with an optional port argument. Add the following boilerplate to the top of the specification: The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT", "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and "OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in RFC 2119. I recommend the use of small capital letters rather than italics for these key words: this can be achieved in HTML with <small>MUST</small>, <small>SHOULD</small>, etc. or in HTML/CSS with <span style="font-variant: small-caps;">must</span>, etc. -- Unless it was by accident that I had John Cowan offended someone, I never apologized. xxxxxx@ccil.org --Quentin Crisp http://www.ccil.org/~cowan