Amending libraries, versioning
Shiro Kawai
(21 Nov 2022 01:50 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Arthur A. Gleckler
(21 Nov 2022 02:15 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(21 Nov 2022 06:55 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(21 Nov 2022 12:53 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Arthur A. Gleckler
(22 Nov 2022 19:46 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
John Cowan
(22 Nov 2022 23:00 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
shiro.kawai@xxxxxx
(22 Nov 2022 23:25 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
John Cowan
(23 Nov 2022 02:29 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Shiro Kawai
(23 Nov 2022 03:31 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Shiro Kawai
(23 Nov 2022 04:37 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(23 Nov 2022 10:07 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 07:05 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(23 Nov 2022 10:05 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 10:09 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(23 Nov 2022 10:42 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 11:11 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 11:17 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(23 Nov 2022 11:33 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
John Cowan
(24 Nov 2022 22:39 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(24 Nov 2022 23:10 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
John Cowan
(24 Nov 2022 23:50 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(25 Nov 2022 09:23 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(25 Nov 2022 10:48 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(25 Nov 2022 13:03 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Feeley
(25 Nov 2022 13:29 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Arthur A. Gleckler
(25 Nov 2022 16:01 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(25 Nov 2022 17:31 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(25 Nov 2022 17:56 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(25 Nov 2022 22:46 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(26 Nov 2022 11:32 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Arthur A. Gleckler
(25 Nov 2022 04:35 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(25 Nov 2022 07:01 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(25 Nov 2022 18:38 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Feeley
(25 Nov 2022 22:31 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(26 Nov 2022 09:24 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Shiro Kawai
(23 Nov 2022 11:36 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 11:45 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Feeley
(23 Nov 2022 13:58 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 14:23 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(23 Nov 2022 15:16 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 15:22 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(23 Nov 2022 15:54 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(23 Nov 2022 17:29 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Arthur A. Gleckler
(23 Nov 2022 23:59 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Lassi Kortela
(24 Nov 2022 08:20 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
John Cowan
(24 Nov 2022 22:06 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning
Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen
(25 Nov 2022 07:09 UTC)
|
Re: Amending libraries, versioning Lassi Kortela (23 Nov 2022 11:25 UTC)
|
> If on the gripping hand we are to say that *any* change to a SRFI > requires a marker of incompatibility including bug fixes, then we need a > completely new SRFI number for each fix, in which case we cannot import > both SRFI M and SRFI N. If we are to avoid that, we must have libraries > (srfi 128), (srfi 162), and (srfi 162 butnot 128). Once we get up to > five possible bug fixes, we end up with 32 libraries. Depends on the nature of the bug. If the buggy facility is useless to everyone, it's probably fine to fix the bug in the spec. Implementations will upgrade eventually (after a several years), and conservative code can avoid using the facility until then. If the buggy behavior is commonly and successfully worked around, and the bug fix would break the workarounds, it's better not to fix the bug. > Using features makes things worse: we need a new feature name for every > bug fix, and we need a mechanism to say which features a given library > supports. Agreed. Empirically, several Scheme implementations' feature lists are already starting to fill up with stuff that should probably go elsewhere.