Re: SRFI 185: Linear adjustable-size strings
Per Bothner 24 Feb 2020 18:53 UTC
Am I missing something in the translate-space-to-newline example?
There seems to be a missing
(set! result ....)
wrapping each call to string-linear-append!.
FWIW: I've expressed before my skepticism of linear-update procedures.
I think it's an inherently hard-to-use error-prone way of working.
Changing string-replace! and string-append! to macros would have
the same portability and performance benefits.
My suggestion: Define a new SRFI that is the same as SRFI-118, except
that string-replace! and string-append! are syntax.
On a Kawa-like-system:
(define-syntax string-append!
(syntax-rules ()
((_ r s ...)
(begin
(srfi-118-string-append! r s...)
(set! r r) ;; to catch misuse
))))
Portable implementation:
(define-syntax string-append!
(syntax-rules ()
((_ r s ...)
(set! r (internal-string-linear-append! r s...)))))
If you're going to put my name on this, you should note my
lack of endorsement.
--
--Per Bothner
xxxxxx@bothner.com http://per.bothner.com/