New draft (#6) and last call for comments on SRFI 225: Dictionaries Arthur A. Gleckler (16 Mar 2022 18:13 UTC)
Re: New draft (#6) and last call for comments on SRFI 225: Dictionaries Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen (23 Mar 2022 19:22 UTC)

Re: New draft (#6) and last call for comments on SRFI 225: Dictionaries Marc Nieper-Wißkirchen 23 Mar 2022 19:22 UTC

I have already given feedback and won't repeat myself here. Should I
have the time to do so one day, I will try to fix what has to be fixed
in my opinion by writing a new SRFI. I think that getting this right
is very important because it is about a unifying interface and should
be able to serve as a good model for future APIs covering generic
algorithms for certain types of data structures.

Am Mi., 16. März 2022 um 19:13 Uhr schrieb Arthur A. Gleckler
<xxxxxx@speechcode.com>:
>
> I've just published draft #6 of SRFI 225. It was submitted by John Cowan, co-author of the SRFI.
>
> This SRFI went through a last-call period in November, but substantial changes were made as a result, so I'm extending the last-call period so that reviewers will have one last chance to submit corrections and feedback before we finalize the SRFI.
>
> In particular, I appeal to anyone reading this to try the sample implementation, run the tests, and send feedback about your results.
>
> If you're interested in this SRFI, please give your feedback via the SRFI 225 mailing list before 2022-03-24. After that, assuming that no major revisions are required, we will declare it final. It is important that we get your feedback before 2022-03-24. If that deadline is too soon for you, but you would like to contribute, please let me know so that I can extend the last-call period.
>
> Here is the commit summary:
>
> MN-W review
> improved rationale
> dto and find-update
> srfi125 find-update add thunk indirection to enforce tail position
> change generator implementation to use continuation based approach
> removed subset and interval procs
> Update srfi-225.html
> update implementation
> update implementation dependency
> make 125, 126 impure only
> fix srfi 125 implementation
> copy edits w.r.t. "or not"
> Drop trailing whitespace.
> Fix errors reports by W3C HTML Validator.
> Publish sixth draft.
>
> Here's the diff:
>
> https://github.com/scheme-requests-for-implementation/srfi-225/compare/draft-5..draft-6
>
> Regards,
>
>
> SRFI Editor