fl+* in gambit-lib/srfi/276.sld Bradley Lucier 01 Nov 2026 17:28 UTC

Peter:

Gambit doesn't use the C library fma anywhere. Github head uses the
relatively slow code

https://github.com/gambit/gambit/blob/f1c787a000fbb50132af79a1bdf6c7610d430c9b/lib/_num.scm#L12716

which works on the Javascript and Python back ends, too. So I don't
understand the code in gambit-lib/srfi/276.sld  where the value of
fl-fast-fl+* depends on C's FP_FAST_FMA.  I'd say that fast-fl+* should
probably be false on Gambit.

The most recent release 4.9.8 has the buggy version

(define-prim&proc (fl+* (x flonum)
                         (y flonum)
                         (z flonum))
   (if (and (flfinite? x) (flfinite? y))
       (if (flfinite? z)
           (let ((x (exact x))
                 (y (exact y))
                 (z (exact z)))
             (inexact (+ (* x y) z)))
           z)
       (fl+ (fl* x y) z)))

which may be why you needed to redefine fl+* in gambit-lib/srfi/276.sld,
but I don't think it's because of musl.

Brad