Email list hosting service & mailing list manager

SRFI-48 incorrect mutation of literal list in example? Sudarshan S Chawathe (01 Jan 2016 02:32 UTC)
Re: SRFI-48 incorrect mutation of literal list in example? Sudarshan S Chawathe (03 Jan 2016 01:44 UTC)
Re: SRFI-48 incorrect mutation of literal list in example? Arthur A. Gleckler (01 Jan 2016 18:28 UTC)

SRFI-48 incorrect mutation of literal list in example? Sudarshan S Chawathe 01 Jan 2016 02:32 UTC

[Resending from subscribed email address; sorry if duplicate.]

I believe the following example in SRFI-48 document is incorrect in R5RS
and beyond, as it mutates a literal constant.

  (format "~w" (let ( (c '(a b c)) ) (set-cdr! (cddr c) c) c))
  ; => "#1=(a b c . #1#)"

I realize this SRFI has been finalized for a while (and I am not aware
of any protocol for errata), but at least the mailing list archives may
serve as a record that could help someone down the road (assuming I am
not mistaken about the above).

[I guess this "outs" me as a format string user.  I promise to use it
only very sparingly and cautiously, and I will try to kick the habit in
the new year.]

Regards,

-chaw