Final comments, mostly editorial
John Cowan
(27 Nov 2013 23:59 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
Per Bothner
(28 Nov 2013 03:52 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
John Cowan
(28 Nov 2013 04:07 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
John Cowan
(28 Nov 2013 04:10 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
Per Bothner
(28 Nov 2013 04:46 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
John Cowan
(28 Nov 2013 04:51 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
Per Bothner
(07 Dec 2013 01:24 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
John Cowan
(07 Dec 2013 19:24 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
Per Bothner
(08 Dec 2013 08:37 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
John Cowan
(08 Dec 2013 17:13 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial
Per Bothner
(08 Dec 2013 20:27 UTC)
|
Re: Final comments, mostly editorial John Cowan (08 Dec 2013 23:23 UTC)
|
Per Bothner scripsit: > I've changed my mind, and I disagree. I looked at the specifications for > "XML literals" in XQuery and ECMAScript for XML, and as far as I can tell, > both allow ">" without even mentioning the "]]>" issue. Okay, that convinces me. > The characters & and < are special and need to be escaped. > > The character > does not have to be escaped, but it is good style > to always do so, as it makes it easier to visually distinguish it > from markup. (The MicroXML proposal does not even allow unquoted >.) > If an XML-node value containing > in element or attribute content > is written, an implementation *should* write the escaped form >. > The XML and HTML 4.x standards do not allow the literal text ]]> in > element content, for historical reasons of SGML-compatibility. For > this reason an implementation of this specification *may* warn if > literal ]]> is seen. I'm okay with that, provided you add "and *must* write the escaped form ]]> if the XML is written", since that is no longer the domain of XML literals but of XML itself. -- How they ever reached any conclusion at all <xxxxxx@ccil.org> is starkly unknowable to the human mind. http://www.ccil.org/~cowan --"Backstage Lensman", Randall Garrett