> The important thing here is not the method of collection: reading through logs, javascript-based collection, or updating a database directly in the server-side code. The important thing is type of data and the dissemination. What is collected and who is it sent to.
>
> On one end of the spectrum we have Google Analytics that collects as much as it can, and sends it into Google, and on the other end there is totally stateless servers (as Scheme users we should know a thing or two about side effects). In the EU, it is debatable if the Google Analytics end of the spectrum is even legal, but it is definitely a no-no for scheme.org. I would like us to be as close to the stateless end as possible, while still allowing things like a usage counter or other types of hopefully benign statistics.

Agreed. Detailed analytics also tends to rely on brittle and complicated
technology.

> (I don't think it's a good idea that I meddle too deeply in this, but a more privacy-preserving way to present the counters is to only update them infrequently, like once a day or once a week. This also scales when we have 1 million hits per second in the future.)
>
> So, even logs is something that can be used for tracking, but if we rotate the logs frequently enough and only use it for debugging and very coarse statistics, that's fine.

A cron job to analyze the nginx logs and update the report daily or
weekly would be quite close to that.

> We should really try to have proper written rules for this, and consensus is better than me occasionally answering emails. But the whole point of the current organisation of scheme.org is that Lassi gets things done, and I don't, so I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for me to come up with something.

Yes, we should have a written agreement. My standard test case is,
Scheme.org should enable people who don't like each other to work under
the same roof. If that becomes difficult, then people will go to other
sites, the community will be more fragmented, information won't flow and
work will be duplicated.

https://www.scheme.org/charter/ is an incomplete draft. We should
gradually finish it. Comments on all aspects of the charter are very
welcome.