First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (22 Mar 2013 06:32 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Alan Manuel Gloria (22 Mar 2013 09:23 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (22 Mar 2013 12:49 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification John Cowan (22 Mar 2013 13:52 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (22 Mar 2013 21:58 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (23 Mar 2013 02:12 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (25 Mar 2013 00:07 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (26 Mar 2013 04:20 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (26 Mar 2013 05:07 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification John Cowan (26 Mar 2013 08:48 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Alan Manuel Gloria (26 Mar 2013 09:03 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification John Cowan (26 Mar 2013 09:28 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (26 Mar 2013 12:04 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (26 Mar 2013 13:13 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (26 Mar 2013 05:08 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (26 Mar 2013 21:49 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (27 Mar 2013 01:43 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (27 Mar 2013 03:49 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (27 Mar 2013 05:24 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Alan Manuel Gloria (27 Mar 2013 07:30 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (27 Mar 2013 13:01 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Alan Manuel Gloria (28 Mar 2013 02:20 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (28 Mar 2013 02:45 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (27 Mar 2013 21:31 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver (30 Mar 2013 16:12 UTC)
Re: First impressions of the specification David A. Wheeler (30 Mar 2013 18:15 UTC)
Re: OT: Formatting Lisp code from the command line Mark H Weaver (30 Mar 2013 21:36 UTC)
Re: OT: Formatting Lisp code from the command line John Cowan (30 Mar 2013 21:45 UTC)

Re: First impressions of the specification Mark H Weaver 23 Mar 2013 02:12 UTC

"David A. Wheeler" <xxxxxx@dwheeler.com> writes:

> Mark H Weaver:
>> I'm sorry to say that I find that
>> section extraordinarily unclear.
>
> I wonder - would it be better if we rewrote the spec using the
> BNF as a template?  That would at least make it easier to
> follow the BNF that follows, and since the BNF actually
> implements the notation, it's clearly formal enough :-).

It's an idea worth considering.  One way or another, I definitely think
that the "Basic specification" section needs to be completely rewritten
from scratch.  It will not be enough to clarify individual points.  It
needs to be fundamentally reorganized, IMO anyway.  I'm not yet sure
what the best approach will be.

    Regards,
      Mark