Re: Reasons for withdrawal

Show/hide message thread

Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (28 Oct 2003 20:35 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Tom Lord (28 Oct 2003 21:24 UTC)

RE: Reasons for withdrawal Anton van Straaten (28 Oct 2003 22:05 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (28 Oct 2003 22:36 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (28 Oct 2003 22:44 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (28 Oct 2003 23:22 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Tom Lord (29 Oct 2003 02:50 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 03:19 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Tom Lord (29 Oct 2003 03:31 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 03:38 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 04:36 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 05:02 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 05:32 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Taylor Campbell (28 Oct 2003 22:56 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Taylor Campbell (28 Oct 2003 23:06 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (28 Oct 2003 23:16 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (28 Oct 2003 23:28 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (28 Oct 2003 23:42 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 00:13 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 01:00 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 01:41 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Tom Lord (29 Oct 2003 03:03 UTC)

RE: Reasons for withdrawal Anton van Straaten (29 Oct 2003 05:31 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 05:54 UTC)

RE: Reasons for withdrawal Anton van Straaten (29 Oct 2003 06:40 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 06:44 UTC)

RE: Reasons for withdrawal Anton van Straaten (29 Oct 2003 07:31 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 07:34 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Thien-Thi Nguyen (29 Oct 2003 14:08 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (28 Oct 2003 21:28 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (28 Oct 2003 22:02 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (28 Oct 2003 22:22 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Jim White (28 Oct 2003 22:15 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Shiro Kawai (29 Oct 2003 01:25 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 01:44 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 04:10 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 04:53 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 05:10 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 05:17 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 05:31 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 01:49 UTC)

API conflicts (Was: Re: Reasons for withdrawal) Shiro Kawai (29 Oct 2003 05:48 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Shiro Kawai (29 Oct 2003 06:03 UTC)

Re: API conflicts scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 17:40 UTC)

Re: API conflicts (Was: Re: Reasons for withdrawal) Bradd W. Szonye (29 Oct 2003 06:03 UTC)

Re: API conflicts (Was: Re: Reasons for withdrawal) scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 14:19 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Shiro Kawai (29 Oct 2003 22:25 UTC)

Re: API conflicts scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 22:41 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Taylor Campbell (29 Oct 2003 23:58 UTC)

Re: API conflicts (Was: Re: Reasons for withdrawal) Taylor Campbell (29 Oct 2003 21:40 UTC)

A possible solution? bear (29 Oct 2003 22:59 UTC)

RE: A possible solution? Anton van Straaten (30 Oct 2003 07:40 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 10:07 UTC)

RE: A possible solution? bear (30 Oct 2003 15:13 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 15:20 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 15:27 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 15:39 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 15:43 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 16:11 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? bear (30 Oct 2003 17:02 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? Tom Lord (30 Oct 2003 19:58 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 20:15 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? bear (30 Oct 2003 20:53 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 21:07 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? Taylor Campbell (30 Oct 2003 21:08 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 21:11 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 21:17 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? bear (30 Oct 2003 23:11 UTC)

Re: A possible solution? Alex Shinn (31 Oct 2003 03:03 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Shiro Kawai (29 Oct 2003 23:19 UTC)

Re: API conflicts scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 00:26 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 05:32 UTC)

Re: API conflicts bear (30 Oct 2003 06:22 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 06:23 UTC)

Re: API conflicts scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 13:54 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 14:01 UTC)

Re: API conflicts scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 14:16 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 14:29 UTC)

Re: API conflicts scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 14:58 UTC)

Re: API conflicts Bradd W. Szonye (30 Oct 2003 15:22 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Tom Lord (29 Oct 2003 01:50 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Alex Shinn (29 Oct 2003 03:06 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 03:18 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Tom Lord (29 Oct 2003 03:29 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 03:37 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Alex Shinn (29 Oct 2003 06:16 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (29 Oct 2003 14:25 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Alex Shinn (30 Oct 2003 02:19 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx (30 Oct 2003 04:42 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal Alex Shinn (30 Oct 2003 06:22 UTC)

Re: Reasons for withdrawal scgmille@xxxxxx 29 Oct 2003 03:38 UTC

Show/hide attachments

On Tue, Oct 28, 2003 at 07:44:55PM -0800, Tom Lord wrote:
>
>     > From: xxxxxx@freenetproject.org
>
>     > <chuckle> Nice try.  I'll say it again.  Withdrawal is only
>     > necessary if=20 there are fundamental flaws throught the SRFI.
>     > The opposite is true,=20 there are some flaws in very limited
>     > parts of the SRFI.
>
>
> You want valuable feedback?  Withdraw it.  You don't?  Fine, your
> finalized 44 is an example of what not to do.  I'll be sure to cite it
> as such at the first opportunity.

Again, there is still room for discussion before finalization without
withdrawal.  Only you and Bradd seem to think its a finalize now or
withdraw situation.

	Scott