I'll try to understand what you're looking for from another angle.

If you want:

- Free-form proposals, automatically accepted into the system.

- Ability for anyone to easily comment under the proposal.

then starting a r/schemereview sub-reddit would seem to accomplish
exactly this goal. We wouldn't even need to make a new website since
many people are already signed into Reddit or can sign up quickly.

In fact, if someone wants to make r/schemereview, I don't have anything
against that.

The goal I have in mind is something more complicated:

- #1 priority is high quality proposals.

- Ability to have complex discussions about the proposals.

- Proposals and discussions fully archived.

- Proposals beautifully laid out on a website.

- More people is good, but not if quality suffers too much.

- Ease of use is good, but not if quality suffers too much.

In other words, just like SRFI, but without the deadlines and the tight
focus on Scheme implementations.